发新话题
打印

请假一个狒狒逻辑的题

请假一个狒狒逻辑的题

Joseph: My encyclopedia says that the mathematician Pierre de Fermat died in 1665 without leaving behind any written proof for a theorem that he claimed nonetheless to have proved. Probably this alleged theorem simply cannot be proved, since---as the article points out---no one else has been able to prove it. Therefore it is likely that Fermat was either lying or else mistaken when he made his claim.
Laura: Your encyclopedia is out of date. Recently someone has in fact proved Fermat’s theorem. And since the theorem is provable, your claim---that Fermat was lying or mistaken---clearly is wrong.

问题: Which one of the following most accurately describes a reasoning error in Laura’s argument?


答案是C.
It mistakes something that is necessary for its conclusion to follow for something that ensures that the conclusion follows.

不好意思,我比较笨读了多次还是不能理解选项C的意思。而且,也没弄懂狒狒的介绍,特请教各位高手!
谢谢,请不吝赐教!

TOP

C选项的意思是:
Laura错误地将一个结论成立的必要条件当作了一个结论成立的充分条件。
具体到这道题来说
如果要说Fermat没有说谎或犯错误,那必须要现在有人能够证明出这个猜想(这是必要而非充分条件,也就是说即使现在有人证明除了Fermat的猜想,Fermat当时还是有可能说了谎或者在证明的时候犯了错误)
本帖最近评分记录

TOP

不胜感谢!解释的非常清楚!

TOP

发新话题